rate_review Reviews

Great story!! I love your interpretation of the characters and how Howl would behave. Nicely done!

=^..^=

Diolch yn fawr i chi! Thanks very much for writing this. It's a great story, your characterization is spot on. I also think it's fantastic that you made the effort to include the Welsh since Howell's Welsh identity is so much a part of who he is. Only thing, though, is that you forgot to include a translation at the end of... I think, chapter 5, it was. Since you were so careful to do it for every other chapter, it was probably just an oversight.

this is an awesome story, and your style is very mature, in the best of ways. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Ah, I just want to thank you for writing this delightful story. I am not very skilled writer, thus I cant really review the writing style, but I try my best. I liked especially depiction of Howls personality, the insight of his thoughts - I haven't read the book, but I found him here quite mature and really believable. The special Calcifer input was really interesting /the shell and exploration of human feeling/. The planning of the story was also very well done. It was really exciting. Many thanks for the story. It will be really hard to find some similar story of this quality - I do have the feeling that asking you to share more stories is pointless, since this ff feels like there was all said what was needed to be. Anyway, its still a pity C":

I really loved this story. You should post it on mediaminer.

I like this. It's well thought out and it gives some very good insight to Howl's issues. I like the idea that Calcifer gets a body too. Howl definetly walks into his own troubles though, but he's just as devious in this story as in the book and gets out of them fairly well. It was very well written.