I made an account just to leave a review. I just had to tell you how amazing this story was. It's incredibly well written. I was taken aback (in a good way) at how fast things turned dark and went to hell. I was not expecting that. Moving on, I love happy endings and I hate sad, tragic ending so, but this is the first time I didn't feel that way. It's weird, but I actually thought the sad ending was the better of the three. And that's because I didn't think it was fair for Lucy to go on and have a happily married life with Gray after messing up Natsu. Don't get me wrong, I am in NO WAY defending what he did to her, but she tortured him mentally and made him snap. So yeah, I liked the sad and neutral endings equally, but didn't care for the happy ending, as weird as that sounds lol. But overall you did a great job with this and you should be proud. I hope you continue writing : )