Adult-FanFiction.org : Anime

Fight Me, Bite Me	By : Rhov Category: +. to F > Fairy Tail Views: 39446 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 3
Disclaimer: Fairy Tail is the property of Hiro Mashima. I make no money, I just do this for my own pleasure.

Chapter List
- 3
- 4
- 5
Chapter 4
A Fucking Checklist
Natsu woke up already handcuffed to the hotel bed's headboard. Drowsy and cranky with sleepiness, he glared around the room until he saw Gray sitting in a chair by a desk, writing on a piece of paper. At the sound of the metal links clanking, the ice wizard set his pen down and looked over.
"Sorry for the cuffs, but I wanted to make sure you didn't escape from me again like you did last night. We need to talk."
Natsu frowned. "Uh-oh. Whenever someone says that, it usually means I'm in trouble."
Gray laughed silently and shook his head. "No, more like I'm the one who messed up and should be in trouble. I messed up bad earlier. I've spent the past hour coming up with that checklist you mentioned yesterday," he explained, tapping his finger on the sheet of hotel room stationary. "Most of the points on my usual checklist are stuff we've already tried, so this list is shorter than normal."
"A fucking checklist? Seriously?"
"A checklist of fucking, yes," Gray said with complete solemnity. "I have some really bizarre kinks, so something like this is needed."
"Do you do this every time you wanna fuck around with someone?"
Gray stared hard at him for ten whole seconds before quietly whispering, "Is that what this is to you? Fucking around?"
Natsu froze at the caustic words. "I … I don't even know. I mean, yesterday was just so random and sudden. I haven't really had time to think clearly."
"Then we'll skip to question number five. Are you okay with an exclusive sexual relationship?"
"Exclusive?" Natsu muttered. Him and Gray … being exclusive. It made him blush. "A-are you asking me out?"
"If that's what you want. This isn't fucking around to me, Natsu. Still, asking you out doesn't necessarily mean we'd be exclusive. Some couples prefer not to be."
"I consider dating as meaning exclusiveness. I thought that's what we agreed upon."
"So we did. Okay, then let's back up to question four: Are you okay with an open relationship?"
Natsu felt dizzy. He also felt an urge to go to the bathroom. "Can we discuss this after I pee?"
"No. Look, I only take one partner at a time, but if you want more than one, then that's something I need to know. I can compromise to some extent, but I don't want you cheating behind my back."
"No! No, just one at a time."
"Would you want a threesome if I suggested it?"
Natsu blinked in shock. "I … guess I'd be okay with that. So long as it's someone we both know, someone who we can definitely trust with … with … this secret." The handcuffs clanked again, as if needing to remind Gray that Natsu felt ashamed about his need to be restrained.
"I don't have anyone in mind at the moment. It's just a question. Can I kiss your lips?"
"Haven't we done that?"
"I have a whole list of locations. Lips, cheeks, neck, nipples, belly button, cock—"
"I have to pee here. It's fine, all of it."
"Touching: we've done just about all that," he hummed. "Are you okay having your nipples licked, and with licking my nipples?"
"Yes to both."
"Would you be okay licking or sucking my feet?"
"Whoa … uh, yeah. Totally."
"Can I lick your feet?"
"If you really want to, but I don't think that'll get me off."
"Can I touch you in a sexual way without asking permission?"
"Not in public."
Gray skimmed down and checked off something. "Noted. No public sexual touching without permission. But in private?"
"Sure, if you wanna touch, do it. You don't need to ask."
"Some people are sensitive about that. Are you okay touching me in a sexual way in public?"
"Like earlier in the hot springs?"
"Yes."
"I … well … only if no one can see us."
"Can I touch you in a sexual way in public if I ask permission?"
Natsu thought about it, and his brow began to tense up.
"It's like what we did earlier today."
"I know," he snapped, but still he thought it over. "It's okay so long as no one sees, but I'll probably have to stop you before I get to the point of needing to be restrained."
"Can I touch you in a nonsexual but still romantic way in public, both with or without permission?"
"Do you mean like holding hands?"
"Yes, or caressing your face or rubbing your thigh. Just friendly or romantic touches."
"Do we want others to know about us?"
"That's up to you," Gray replied. "I'm fine if our friends know about us, just not the kinky stuff. If you want to kiss or hug or hold hands in public, I'm okay with a little PDA, so long as we keep it discreet."
Natsu's brow creased as he thought about it. "I'll say yes for now, but I need to think about whether I actually want the guild to know. If they know we're lovers, they'll question how I got bruises around my wrists, and it'd be harder to keep everything else secret."
"Good point. We'll discuss that more later, so a provisional 'yes' to public romantic touches, both with and without permission."
As Gray wrote in some notes, Natsu thought about how a relationship like that would be, to hold hands walking down the streets of Magnolia, to sneak in kisses while cuddled together in a corner of the guild hall, openly discussing romantic dates with their friends—We haven't even gone on a real date, unless the hot spring counts—and overall just being a normal couple … on the outside. In private, they could do all the kinkiness they wanted. It was such a nice thought, a happy future, and it made Natsu blush warmly.
"Are you okay having semen on your body?"
That warm, fuzzy feeling was instantly set ablaze in a sea of embarrassment. "I thought I made that obvious just now."
"I want to make sure. Are you okay with your semen on my body?"
"Yeah."
"Fruits or other food items on your body?"
"If you want, but isn't that weird?"
"Licking chocolate sauce off a lover is actually really fun. We'll try it some time. What about things like oil, lotion, juice, champaign, caramel, slime, foam, or mud on your body?"
"Uh … I'm not gonna ask, but … sure, why the hell not?"
"What about urine, feces, or vomit on your body?"
"Wait, you mean pissing and shitting on me?" Natsu cried out. Warm fuzzy feelings: officially obliterated.
"One or the other, or all of them."
Natsu cringed down. "Vomit and poop, no. I don't want you to poop or puke on me."
"Would you want to piss on me?"
"On … you?" Natsu eyes widened. "Uh, actually … yeah. That sounds hot. Weird, but hot."
"Can I piss on you?"
"Only if we're in a shower and I can wash off right away."
Gray jotted the conditions down. "Would you be willing to drink my urine?"
"Now you're just screwing with me," he grumbled.
Gray looked up from the chart, and his face was dead serious. "I'm not. It's something I think would be really erotic, making you drink my piss. It's sterile and safe, I don't have diseases, and obviously I wouldn't do that if I had a kidney infection or anything, but I have to warn you, it doesn't taste good. Still, it'd be really hot to make you do that."
Natsu's stomach twisted. He used to think his kinks were bizarre, but Gray was on a whole other level. "I honestly have no clue what piss tastes like, but I'm gonna say let's put that one as a maybe for way in the future, and only if you're willing to drink mine in return."
"Noted, and actually, I'd love to."
When Gray said that, Natsu's jaw dropped. The urge in his bladder increased as he thought about letting loose and pissing into Gray's eager mouth. However, the arousal that thought created made the urge to pee hurt. His thighs twisted together as his bladder began to ache.
Gray slowly raised his eyes from the paper and watched Natsu twisting with urgency. He unconsciously licked his lips as he saw the discomfort in the Dragon Slayer's face. "Do you really have to pee?" he asked quietly, feeling his pulse increase.
"I already told you I did," Natsu snapped crankily.
Gray swallowed hard as he felt heat pooling in his groin. "How bad is it?"
"Not so bad where I'm gonna piss myself yet, but my bladder is starting to hurt." Natsu noticed a change in smell in the room, and he looked over to Gray in shock. He smelled the hormones of arousal, and Gray's face looked almost completely overcome by lustful fascination. The stiffness in the boxers was a sure sign that the smell was coming from him. Was he really getting aroused seeing Natsu needing to pee? Natsu smirked a little. "You're one kinky bastard."
"You're one to talk!" Gray snapped defensively. He tried to focus back down on the checklist and ignore the way his heart pounded at the thought of Natsu struggling not to piss himself. "Okay, you managed to flush the ice water out of your ass, but would you be willing to do more? Are you okay taking a crap while I watch?"
Natsu twisted again, but this time he curled his lips. Between his need to pee, the way some of these things Gray listed made him hard, and the pure disturbing images some of the suggestions evoked, he was having one of the worst cranky wake-ups of his life.
"M-maybe. I never really thought about that. But, not standing up like that time. If I happen to be taking a dump on the toilet, and you happen to be in the bathroom, that's fine."
"Would you be okay watching me take a crap, and not in the toilet?"
Natsu grimaced. "I … wouldn't be utterly against it if you got off that way, but I can tell you, it's not gonna turn me on."
"Don't know unless you try. Can I watch you piss?"
"I'm ready to piss now, bastard!" He yanked on the handcuffs harshly.
That gleam of lecherous fascination returned as Gray smirked seductively. "Can I watch?"
Heat seared Natsu's cheeks. The twitching in his cock increased as the cold air against his naked body became even more pronounced. "Fine, I guess that's okay. And I know you're gonna ask, so same for watching you. Watching others use the bathroom isn't arousing to me, but if you want to have me watch, I will."
"What about using catheters?"
Natsu raised a wary eyebrow. "How the hell does that work?"
"I stick a catheter up your dick and either don't let you piss or force you to piss where I want."
"I … don't think so. Actually, no. Big no."
"Okay. Saves me money on buying them. Ice was fine. What about fire?"
Natsu arched an eyebrow. "Really? You have to ask?"
"Okay, dumb question. What about wax?"
"Uh, wax?"
"Dripping hot candle wax on you."
Natsu's gaze drifted, and as Gray watched, he noticed the Dragon Slayer's arousal grew.
"Natsu?"
"Fuck yes," he said hoarsely.
Gray chuckled at the eagerness. He drew a star next to that one. Definitely something to try in the near future. "Um … okay, this will sound weird, but just let me know if any of these are okay: razors, needles, knives, swords, hot pokers, branding utensils, or other hot metal surfaces or piercing utensils used on your skin."
"Hell no!"
"Good. Those are hard limits for me, as well. I don't like getting permanent marks, but if you're into that, I can do that to you. Biting until the skin breaks is a big yes for you. I'm usually not into that, but so long as you can heal it with that dragon-lust-spit-healing-thing, then it should be fine. Let's see … ah! You freaked out when I entered you, but it was only triggered by me speaking. Would you be okay if we tried anal sex again, with you as the giver, if we do it without speaking?"
"I dunno. Maybe."
"Would it be better if the lights were off?"
"No, lights on. I want to see you there."
"Can I turn the lights off other times?"
"Not if I'm inside you. If you're the one pounding into me, we can try it, but it's not as fun, right?"
"Depends. Can I blindfold you?"
"I'll give it a try, but I might need to see depending on the situation."
"Can I gag you?"
"Gag me?" Natsu shivered a bit. "No. No gags."
"Okay. You're obviously fine with me masturbating for you, but would you be okay masturbating for me?"
"I … guess so. At least a little bit, but I can't actually get myself off that way. It's never worked. I can't come unless I'm tied up and forced."
"Are you okay giving manual sex? You know, touching me."
"Touching inside your ass was really nice, but I think I can only do that for a little while, and I'd prefer to have at least one hand restrained."
"Same with touching my dick?"
Natsu stiffened. "I … I don't know. Through your clothes is okay, but when we're in the moment … I don't think I trust myself."
"Okay, limited cock touching. Can I use sex toys: dildo, vibrator, butt plug, anal beads, cock rings, testicle cuffs, artificial vagina…?"
"NO!" Natsu screamed, then suddenly he jolted in shock by his own paranoid reaction. "That … that is…"
"See, this is why I have a checklist. Sex toys are a hard limit." He began to write that down.
"A what?"
"It means I absolutely won't use them on you. Do you think you could use a sex toy on me?"
Natsu was still shaking from the near panic attack. "I … I don't know. Probably something like a … a … what are the plastic cocks called?"
"Dildo."
"Yeah, that might be okay. Maybe okay to use something like that on me too. I think a vibrator would be nice," he muttered, blushing slightly, "but something like a fake vagina … no. Hell no."
Gray watched the tightness in Natsu's brow and the way his eyes flitted back and forth. He really wanted to ask what sort of trauma happened in Natsu's past. The curiosity was killing him. However, he had to be respectful. This was not the time for prying into a bitter past.
"Let's go through one at a time. Dildos are okay. Vibrator, yes. Butt plug?"
"What the hell does that do?"
"What it says. It's like a mini rubber dick, plugs your ass, fills you up, so I can use my cock elsewhere."
"Okay, that's fine."
"Anal beads and cock rings?" By Natsu's confused face and silence, Gray realized he truly was inexperienced and likely too innocent for all these kinks. "Anal beads are a string of balls that go up your ass. I don't own any, but I'm willing to buy some. A cock ring goes around your cock, keeps your erection up and prevents you from coming so you last long enough to fully enjoy what I have to give you."
"Oooh, I like that idea."
Gray chuckled at the brightness in Natsu's eyes. "I'll have to buy one."
"Oh, don't go out of your way."
"Nah, I don't mind. I know a little shop. So yes on both." Gray wrote that down and dragged his finger down to the next on the list. "Are you okay with cock and ball restraints?"
"How the hell does that work?"
"Wraps around your cock, usually to keep you from coming, or around your balls to pull them away from your body. You know how your balls draw up just before coming? The restraint makes you really feel that."
"That's kinda … hardcore, I guess. Still, I don't think I'd have a problem with it."
"I'll put that as a maybe. What about nipple clamps?"
"Umm … probably?" Natsu gave a shrug. "I'm not sure what that would be like, but it'd probably be okay."
"How about wearing a chastity belt?"
"Can I still pee in one of those?"
"Of course you can. You just can't touch yourself. I'd like to make you wear one if I have to go on a solo mission. That way you can't masturbate while I'm gone. You'll save all that sexual frustration for me, and only I can release you from your prison."
Natsu felt a wave of dizziness. "Holy crap, I want that," he gasped, and his cock surged at the thought of being trapped, imprisoned, locked away so no one could touch it. He hissed in pain as the attempted arousal reminded him that he had to pee. "Hurry up! I'm ready to piss."
"Oh God…" Gray gasped so softly, a normal person would have missed it, but Natsu's sensitive ears heard the soft hiss. "Okay, um … next one…" Instead, he looked up with interest. "Are you really ready to piss yourself?"
"I can hold it for a few more minutes. Just hurry up."
Gray twisted his hips in the seat to adjust for his arousal. "Erotic electrostimulation?"
"No clue what that is."
"Short version: I zap you. The pain and stimulation can be really pleasurable."
"I'll give it a try, I guess."
"Are you okay with terms of endearment?"
"Call me your cute snuggly dragon and I will punch you in the balls." He watched as Gray began to write that down. "Dude, I was joking."
"I'm not," Gray said seriously. "I'll let you know right now: don't call me Ice Boy, Snow Daddy, Polar Bear, Shades, and sure as hell, don't you dare call me Gray-sama." He shivered slightly at that.
"Juvia would hate that."
"Juvia is why I added that to the list."
"And the others on the list?"
"Old girlfriends or people I don't like."
"I'll probably just keep calling you Droopy-eyed Ice Princess," Natsu said with a cocky smirk.
"Asshole," Gray chuckled.
"I don't have any name I particularly hate, just nothing overly sweet. Oh, and…" Natsu's eyes darkened again. "Don't ever refer to me as Boy. Just … don't."
"Noted. Next question. Are you okay with saying I love you or hearing me say it to you?"
Natsu blinked in shock. "You … love me?"
"It's just a question. Some people really freak out if they hear someone tell them that, or they think it's too embarrassing to say it out loud."
"So then, you don't love me?" If Natsu had been a dog, his ears would have drooped. That was the sort of face Gray saw, and it was precisely what he imagined.
"Just answer the question."
"Not until you answer mine. Do you love me?"
Gray rolled his eyes in frustration. "Something like that…" This was not the time to discuss something so deep. He wanted to get through the checklist. "I'm still trying to sort you out, Natsu. I can determine my own feelings later. I'm not the kind of guy who says words like that on a whim. I can tell you right now, I probably won't say it, or if I do, it won't be often."
Natsu had to admit, he felt disappointed hearing that. He always wanted to have someone who would whisper I love you in his ear. Hesitantly, he mumbled, "Are you okay if I say it to you?"
"It'll embarrass me, so not in public, but in private it's fine."
"I … would probably say it. If I meant it," he added quickly. "And … I'd like to hear it being said to me, but only if you want to."
"Okay." Well, that wasn't awkward or anything! "How do you feel about roleplay?"
"I have no idea what you're talking about."
"Pretending to be something else. Like, dressing up as a police officer, a little schoolboy, a pirate, or pretending you're the dark wizard and I'm the Magic Council soldier."
Natsu began to laugh. "Seriously?"
"I'm not actually into that," Gray assured him. "I just remember that was on my list. Some girls are really into those sorts of things."
Being reminded that Gray had enough sexual experience to even need a list like this, and to have categories geared for women, made Natsu pout with jealousy. "I'm not against it, I guess. Not really my thing, though."
"How about dressing up and acting like an animal, like a dog or cat?"
"Uhhh … not against it, but I don't think that would turn me on."
"We might get you an outfit. Sometimes it's nice to set aside your humanity and act wild like an animal. Are you okay being collared?"
"Just wearing one? Sure."
"Would you be willing to wear one in public?"
"No, nothing kinky in public."
"What if you wore it under your scarf, so no one can see?"
Natsu paused as his heart suddenly fluttered. To wear something as kinky as a collar, a sign that he was the property of Gray Fullbuster, a kink-fanatic, a sexual deviant, to wear that out in public, hidden from sight, feeling the constant fear that his scarf might suddenly shift, someone might see it, and if they saw it, he alone would come under scrutiny … yes, Gray could easily ignore the incident. Natsu wouldn't tell anyone that the collar belonged to Gray. He would suffer the shame alone. Suffer public humiliation! The whole guild would think he was sick, twisted, a pervert … it was the same erotic thrill as earlier that day, fingering Gray in the hot spring. Doing something so naughty, but in a way so no one could see…
"Yeah…" he whispered with a shudder. "I … I'd like that."
Gray had honestly thought he would still say no. Personally, the thought of Natsu wearing his collar, a sign of ownership, out in public was really pushing Gray's comfort level. Then again, what fun was BDSM if you didn't push your limits a bit? Now, as he watched the enthralled gleam in Natsu's eyes as his mind plunged into some sort of masochistic fantasy, Gray put a little star next to Public Collaring and made a mental note to go buy Natsu a nice leather collar. He twisted his hips on the seat as his cock became harder just thinking about it. He needed to keep focused, though. There were still some questions to go.
"Do you mind cross-dressing?"
Natsu snapped out of the fantasy. "What? You want to see me in a dress?"
"More like a corset and stiletto high heels."
"God, that sounds weird," he whispered to himself. "I'll have to think about that. For special occasions, maybe. I don't want to make a habit of it, though. But I'm not buying the clothes. And before you ask, I don't really want to see you dressed as a girl, but if you really wanna, I'm not against it."
"Noted. Now, I just want to make sure: you're okay with whipping, caning, belting, paddling, riding crops, and other forms of impact play, right?"
Natsu smirked seductively. "I liked when you belted me. It hurt … and it felt so good. My ass is still tingling from that."
This time, Gray was the one who felt his cheeks go hot. "I liked that too. I want to do more to you." He gulped down those fantasies for another time. "What parts of your body can I absolutely not touch?"
"Normally, I'm fine with anything, but I might be a little sensitive about my neck. Only touching it. Kissing there is awesome."
"What parts of my body are you not willing to touch?"
Natsu looked over Gray's sculpted body, wearing only boxers with an opened robe draped on. He wanted to touch every inch of it, but … "It's gonna depend. I'm okay with just about anything until I feel too aroused."
"If I were to restrain you, but left you able to move your fingers, could I make you touch me places?"
"I … think that's okay. Actually, I wouldn't mind seeing if I could touch inside your ass so long as my hands are cuffed."
"We'll have to try that."
"Oh, but … not your cock. I mean, at the beginning, I'd like to touch you there, especially through your clothes and watch you enjoy it like that, and maybe if I'm touching you but you're not making me aroused, but … I … I'll probably … hurt you, especially when I'm too horny."
"We'll have to see how far is too horny. Are you okay with me coming in your ass?"
"That … it was okay."
"Can I do it without a condom?"
"Honestly, I might prefer that."
"Are you okay coming in my ass?"
This time Natsu cringed.
"That's a no," Gray realized. "Maybe with a condom?"
"No," he whispered. "Actually, it'd be worse with the condom."
Something about fake vaginas and condoms … Gray would be lying if he said he wasn't curious—and worried—but he let it go. "Would you be okay giving me oral sex?"
Natsu hesitated for a long time. "Maybe if restrained and if you don't touch me."
"Would it be okay if I came in your mouth?"
"Yes, definitely."
"I already tried sucking you and you were okay, but would you be okay if you came in my mouth?"
Natsu again shifted uncomfortably. "Only if you swallow it."
Gray arched an eyebrow. "Mandatory swallowing?"
"Yes. Don't spit it out."
"Wow … okay, I'll note that." What the hell sort of mandate is that? "Would you be okay licking my ass?"
"Actually, that sounds better than sucking your cock."
"And you were okay when I licked your ass, right?"
Natsu's cheeks went bright pink. "That was pretty damn hot."
"I'm glad you liked it. Last ones: Are there any other kinks you specifically enjoy?"
"I don't really know. You've listed a lot that I never even thought about before."
"Are there any you specifically are against?"
"Well, the obvious stuff. No kids, animals, or dead bodies. Don't choke me, that's one I am absolutely against. Nothing that might restrict my breathing, like a gag or covering my nose. Oh, and … okay, this isn't a fetish, but I'd like it if you at least attempt to smell good before we do this. My nose is sensitive, so if you haven't bathed in a week, it's gonna really turn me off. And no using weird smells. No scented candles, incense, strong-smelling oil, and although I can handle light cologne, too much will make me sick. What about you? We should go through this with you, so I know what you want."
"We can later. My normal checklist is longer."
He watched Gray jot down some final notes. "Also," Natsu whispered, "you … you don't have to … make me come. I just want you to know that. Don't feel like that has to happen. I'm … a little afraid."
"About coming?"
"About…" He turned his head aside. "I can't say."
"Natsu, if something is scary, then I definitely need to know about it so I won't do it. I won't ask why it scares you. You're okay with coming, but it seems like you have a lot of specific limitations. That's perfectly fine, but I need to know what those limits are so I don't cross them. The pressure is on me, not on you."
Natsu shifted around on the bed, pulling weakly at his restrained wrists. "It's … about … m-my … stuff."
"Your semen?"
"Yeah," he mumbled. "If you swallow it, that's fine. If it splatters on me or you or on the floor or … if it's out, that's fine. But … when … when it's in something, if it's in your ass, or in a condom, or in a sex toy, or even in a tissue … just … in something … that … that would really make me flip out."
"In … something? Like, if you came in a cup?"
Natsu flinched so hard, the headboard bowed, and his hands began to shake at they clenched tight enough to leave nail marks in Natsu's palms.
"Whoa, okay. Calm down, calm down. I'll put that as a hard limit. We'll never do that. Just keep calm." Gray wrote down everything Natsu had listed along with no semen collection in big letters. He guessed that was the general issue here. "You know, if you have a thing against condoms and your cum being in something, like a vagina, you're gonna have a hard time getting into a relationship with women."
Natsu forced himself to smile weakly over at Gray. "Then maybe I should forget woman and stick to men."
Gray smiled back at him. "Works for me."
"I bet it does." He yanked on the handcuffs. "Now, let me go. I'm seriously ready to piss."
Gray finished the last notes, set the checklist aside, then crossed one leg over his knee and folded his hands together. "Go ahead."
Natsu stared at Gray's cruel smile, sadistic eyes, and domineering posture.
Oh … fuck.

A/N: The "Checklist of Fucking" is based on the checklist used by Charlie and Jamie in the webcomic Khaos Komix, which itself is based on a list of rules and boundaries in a relationship:
www.khaoskomix.com/komix/yesnomaybe3
- 3
- 4
- 5
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Fight Me, Bite Me