Adult-FanFiction.org : Anime

Natsu's Choices	By : Aonika Category: +. to F > Fairy Tail Views: 18210 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 1
Disclaimer: Alas, I do not own Fairy Tail, and I do not make any money from the writing of fanfiction. I just do it for fun, and because all the other jobs where you can torture people and control their lives are illegal.

Chapter List
- 1
- 2
Disclaimer: Alas, I do not own Fairy Tail, and I do not make any money from the writing of fanfiction. I just do it for fun, and because all the other jobs where you can torture people and control their lives are illegal.
A/N: This chapter of the story contains a lemon. The story will not focus on lemons as a major source of content. (Unless you dirty pervs like that sort of thing)
A special thanks to my lovely Betas, iNSaNiTY49 (who has been a huge help with the entire document) and Scarlet Forest, (who has edited a sfw version of this story.) This story would not be anywhere near as good as it is without their help.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“Ambush!” Lucy cried out as the bandit behind her twisted her arm and placed a collar around her neck. She looked around frantically, but Erza was under attack by an overwhelming hoard, and Gray was kind of busy watching her back. Natsu was off somewhere, breaking shit, as was his custom. She elbowed the bandit, knocking him back long enough to grab a key from her belt.
"Open, gate of the lion…Leo!"
When her magic didn't respond, she felt a sinking feeling. Usually when she was in trouble Loki would show up on his own…but for some reason, he wasn't arriving.
“Loki! Please, help me!” Nothing.
Her thoughts raced. 'Is there some sort of spell on the collar to prevent spirits from seeing me? But how could they tell I was a celestial mage? I hadn’t used magic yet…’
She twisted around, yanking her whip from her belt. She managed to take out the bandit creeping up behind her, but she couldn’t keep up with the sheer number of bandits surging her way. Her greatest weapon, her magic, had been sealed, and with it her fate.
****
Gray couldn’t believe how efficiently the trap had been laid. Even Erza was having trouble. He stood guarding her back, but he was running out of magic and he was losing hope fast.
“Shit! Erza!” He spun as he saw a bandit dart past him. “Ice Make: Shield!” He barely managed to fend off the attack aimed at her back. He could feel himself grow weaker. ‘Shit…How long can I keep this up?’
Erza’s requip was slowing. ‘Looks like she’s tiring too. We need to wrap this up…She’s used up way too much magic.’
Gray noticed a bandit poised to strike his friend as he stood observing her. He readied his ice magic, but it didn’t respond. He couldn’t raise a shield in time. “Erza! Look out!”
He threw himself in front of the sword aimed at her back, the blow instead slicing his back open and injuring plenty of organs on its way through. He couldn’t prevent a pained cry, and Erza spun around, becoming distracted at the worst possible moment.
A blast of magic pierced her in the lower chest, and she fell.
Lucy’s pain echoed throughout the entire building in the form of a horrified scream.
****
Natsu was gleefully destroying the bandit's hideout when he heard a sound that made his blood freeze in his veins…Lucy's horrified, agonized screech.
"Lucy!"
He rushed back to the main room, mentally kicking himself for leaving the others. ‘Why do you always run ahead? You’d better get there in time!’
He gestured to Happy just before he reached the room where the others fought. “Stay here!"
He ran into the room, coming to an abrupt halt when he saw the battered bodies of Erza and Gray on the ground, unconscious…bleeding out. A quick sniff informed him they were fading fast. If they weren't treated soon, they would die. ‘So much blood…’ Rage filling his face, fire surrounding him, he strode towards the bandits.
"Tsk tsk. Do you want your friends to die? This one too, of course." The leader, standing above Natsu on a nearby ledge, twisting Lucy's arm, making her cry out again. He could see bruises already covering her skin. Natsu ground to a halt, his flames intensifying.
"How about a deal, hmm?" The man threw down a circular piece of metal…a collar. "Put that on, and my friend here will save those two. Likewise, I won't kill the blonde."
"I'm supposed to believe you'll honor the deal once I actually put the collar on?" Natsu scoffed, edging closer.
"Do you have any choice?" The man raised a brow, twisting Lucy's arm again and tsking softly at him when he got too close. Natsu stopped again, grinding his teeth. "They're dying, Fairy. Tick tock. Time’s up. What do you choose?"
Natsu closed his eyes, anguish filling his face as he struggled with the decision. He suspected the collar had some sort of magic nullifying enchantment on it. It had a weird smell to it. His chance to rescue Lucy and the rest would probably decrease a lot if he took the deal. But…Erza and Gray would die very soon unless he did something, and he couldn’t use healing magic. Even if he managed to free them, he couldn’t heal them. He could smell their lives ebbing out onto the bloodstained ground. He nodded subtly to Happy, trusting him to get help.
"Fine."
Natsu picked up the collar. "But if you let them die, I promise you'll regret it for the rest of your very short life…" He put the collar on and instantly felt the loss of his magic.
"A wise decision." The leader snapped his fingers and a young woman rushed forward. Erza and Gray were enveloped by a blinding light. When Natsu could see again, they seemed fully healed, though they were now wearing collars. Upon closer inspection, Natsu could see that Lucy and the young healer were also wearing them. His thoughts raced in baffled circles. ‘How can the healer use healing magic with the collar on? Does each collar do different things to the victim? I can’t use my magic anymore…how can she?’
"I always keep my promises. You'd do well to remember that." The man smirked. "My name is Chimei. I am the leader of this group. If you wish to avoid untold sorrow, you'll obey me without question. Isn't that right, Li?" As he gestured to the woman, his eyes never left Natsu’s. The young healer, obviously saddened by the capture of Natsu’s group, nodded meekly as she fixed her gaze to the floor.
The leader laughed, an evil sound that sent a shiver down Lucy's spine as she stood listening to the man currently holding her hostage. "Li went against my wishes once…but you regret that now, don't you pet? But my men and I found her sooo entertaining. It’s a shame she didn’t get pregnant, though…We could use a bunch of little healers running around."
Chimei's leer left nothing to the imagination, and Natsu had a sinking feeling deep in his stomach. ‘Rape…He's bragging about rape.’ His eyes snapped to Lucy and a growl built in his throat.
"If you hurt her, I'll fucking KILL YOU!" Natsu screamed, unconsciously taking a threatening step forward.
"Tsk tsk. You'll learn either respect or despair soon, boy." His goons dragged the still groggy Erza and Gray from the room. "Now seems like a good time for your first lesson." A few bandits surrounded Natsu, holding his arms behind him and forcing him to watch as Chimei handed Lucy off to a goon and came close enough to whisper in Natsu’s ear. "My men and I could have a lot of fun with this one. Such a body…such beautiful hair…my god, her face! My men would sire many children on her. She could be the start of a new era, just imagine the spawn we could force on her."
Natsu immediately began fighting like a wild beast, willing to injure himself to get free, all the while screaming death threats. It became hard for the bandits to keep him subdued. He became a dervish of flying kicks and punches. He even bit a few. "Let me go! You bastards! You won't get away with this! I'LL FUCKING KILL YOU!"
"Now, now. Did I say I was going to rape her? No, dear boy. You will be the one to rape her."
Natsu was so surprised by his words that he actually stopped struggling. "What? I'd never do that!"
"You will do it."
"Yeah right. Why would I rape Lucy?" The look of contempt Natsu gave him spoke volumes.
"Because if you don't…my men will. Each and every one of them will use her over and over, as painfully as possible, until she is so full of despair that she eventually, and with a great deal of relief, takes her own life.”
Natsu felt the blood drain from his face as he considered his options. 'No magic…Damn it! I should have fought them before. But Erza and Gray…'
Outwardly subdued now, he whispered "Don’t do this."
The Salamander’s mind was full of bitter determination. ‘If they try to make me rape Lucy, I’ll have to kill them all…without magic. I don’t know how I will…but I will. If Lucy gets hurt, they’ll die.’
"Perhaps if you beg I'll permit you to seduce her instead. I can be merciful." The amusement in his voice made Natsu grit his teeth as hate spread through him.
"Fine." He gritted out. "Please…please. I'll do anything if you'll spare her."
"Surely that isn't the best you can do? It isn't very good begging. It’s like you’re barely into it at all." He pointed at the ground. "On your knees. And put some feeling into it."
Natsu had to take several deep breaths before he trusted himself to speak. In the end it was only the sight of Lucy nervously waiting just out of earshot that calmed him down. After few more deep inhales and slow exhales, he dropped to his knees.
"Please…I'm begging you. Please don't hurt her! Please don't hurt my precious comrades." He looked down, trying to hide the hate he felt, the rage. 'Maybe if he thinks I'm beaten I'll have a chance to take him out.' He mentally raged.
"I'll do anything…just please don't hurt them. Hurt me instead. I freely offer myself in Lucy’s place."

“Very well. You still have to fuck her, but I’ll give you an hour to get her to agree, and even thirty minutes for foreplay.” Chimei smirked. “What do you say when someone does you a favor?”
Natsu ground his teeth. “Thank you.” He rose. Not wanting to risk Lucy, and wanting to reinforce the image of a broken man, he paused. Looking at the ground, hiding his hate, he spoke softly. “May I go to her now?”
Chimei waved a hand, granting permission, and Natsu rushed over, grabbing her hand and pulling her into a nearby corner.
“We need to have sex.” At the look of disbelieving disgust on her face, he sighed. “Okay, don’t get mad, that came out wrong.” He brushed his pink hair back in frustration, trying to figure out how to tell her. ‘I guess I should just tell her everything and get it over with.’ He told himself.
“Either you and I have sex or they’re threatening to gang rape you.”
Her brown eyes widened in fright. “Natsu…” She closed her eyes, and he rushed to comfort her.
“But I won’t…”
“Lucy kick!”
He rubbed his jaw and looked betrayed. “What was that for?!”
“For randomly going up to me and saying ‘Lucy, we need to have sex’! You…you idiot!”
He laughed, unable to stop himself. “Well, how should I have said it?”
“I don’t know.” She fidgeted nervously. “Maybe ‘I’ve got terrible news…’?”
His face fell. “I’m sorry Luce.”
She leaned forward and put a hand on his arm. “It’s not your fault Natsu. And it’s not so bad.” Her voice was full of false cheer. “I’d rather lose my virginity to you than a bandit.”
Natsu’s emotions got the best of him and he had to clear his throat several times before he could speak. “I’m sorry. This is all my fault. I should have fought them. Then you wouldn’t be forced to…” He hung his head.
She hugged him. “But then Erza and Gray would have…they would have died, Natsu. I wasn’t lying before. It isn’t so bad.”
“But you’re a virgin.” He kept his head down, kicking himself. ‘Yeah Natsu, make her comfort you right before she’s forced to give you her virginity. You’re a real asshole, you know?’
“So?” She smirked, inwardly worried at his obvious depression. “I don’t mind…if it’s you.” She winked and gave a thumbs up gesture, trying to cheer him up.
“But…” He spoke so softly she couldn’t hear him.
“Hmm? What was that? I couldn’t hear you.”
“But I’ll probably hurt you.” His voice was small and sad. “I won’t want to…but you’re a virgin…and I’m…” He trailed off again, blushing slightly.
“You’re…?” She prompted, too innocent to guess what he’d been about to say.
He blushed deeper. “I’m…” He sighed and tried again. “I’m…big.”
She stared at him. “Big? What do you mea…?” Heat suffused her face as she suddenly understood what he meant.
“I mean my…” She jumped forward and slapped a hand over his mouth.
“Don’t say it! I understand now!” Face beet red, she screeched “Don’t say it!” again before she took her hand from his mouth.
****
Chimei stepped forward, his customary smirk already in place. “Times up, little fairies. You’ve used up your hour…now it’s time to begin the entertainment.”
Natsu gritted his teeth as he felt Lucy immediately tense up. “It’s okay Lucy. I’m going to be as gentle as I can. I won’t hurt you…” He trailed off, remembering her virginity. “…much.” He finished lamely.
She gave him a sad smile. “It’s okay Natsu. I trust you.”
Chimei growled. “Get on with it already. You have twenty seven minutes until penetration.”
Lucy’s breath hitched. She was obviously scared, and Natsu couldn’t stop the glare he sent Chimei’s way.
“How I use my foreplay time is up to me, asshole.” Inwardly he cursed his lack of self-control. ‘What if he takes it out on Lucy? Think before you speak!’
Chimei blinked at him, but then he gave a hearty laugh and a mocking bow. “As you wish, your lordship.” He walked off, still chuckling. He was willing to be generous. Natsu was going to obey.
Natsu sighed and turned back to Lucy, his mind racing. ‘I don’t want to hurt her…So I’d better get to work.’ He leaned forward and gave her a tender kiss. He started out slow…an extended peck, a light brush of his finger down her neck. When he felt her relax a little, he darted his tongue against her bottom lip.
She gave a small sigh and he felt himself begin to react, blood rushing to his groin as he cradled her tighter. She began to take a more active role in their kiss, leaning into him as she kissed him back with passion.
Natsu knew they didn’t have long, and truth be told he could feel lust beginning to cloud his mind. ‘I had no idea how arousing it would be to kiss Lucy…’
He reached under her shirt, his hands cupping her breasts through her bra as he leaned down to kiss her neck. He smiled when her breath hitched and he could smell the enticing scent of her arousal.
“I’m sorry sweetie, I’m going to have to go a little fast.” His voice was tender, tinged with arousal. His head dipped down to taste her nipple through her bra, humming with satisfaction when she gave a mewling cry. He began to trace her nipples with his tongue, alternating between them, using his fingers to rub, pinch, and circle the one his mouth neglected. When he could smell her arousal intensify and she was squirming and moaning softly, he began to kiss his way down her body.
“Ah…N-Natsu…That…that feels good…” She gave a contented sigh, unaware of the fact that she was pressing against him, hands clutching his pink hair in her fists.
Natsu smiled before he suddenly pressed his mouth against her panties, tonguing her through the cloth. He started licking her with the intention of bringing her pleasure, but it quickly changed into a more selfish motivation. ‘Her scent…the taste of her…I need more.’ Without thought he yanked her panties down and returned to his feast, adding a finger tracing her opening.
She cried out in unadulterated pleasure. She would have collapsed if he hadn’t used one hand to support her. She began to urgently rock against him, close to orgasm. Natsu slowed the movement of his tongue, intentionally keeping her on edge. He began to thrust a finger in and out of her, curling it, searching for that perfect spot. He knew he’d found it when she collapsed into his arms again and threw her head back.
Lucy couldn’t believe that this was Natsu. ‘How did he get so good at this? I’ve never seen him with a girl…he always seems so oblivious…’ Lucy’s thoughts cut off as he added a second finger, stretching her gently as he began to suck on her clit. “Oh god…NATSU!”
He began to trust his fingers faster, still being gentle, finding that little spot inside her and rubbing it mercilessly as he licked and sucked at her clit. He could smell the change as she hurtled toward orgasm, and he pulled back. He continued to fuck her with his fingers, keeping her on edge. He gave a masculine chuckle of satisfaction when she gave a frustrated cry and yanked his hair. He added a third finger, going back to gently licking her as he got her used to a little more girth.
A small part of his mind registered that they were running short on time, and he began to thrust his fingers faster, returning his mouth to her clit. He guided her down to lay on the floor and finally allowed himself to push her over the edge.
He yanked his pants down and covered her body with his own while she was still writhing in pleasure. He took advantage of her distraction to ease himself slowly inside of her, being careful not to go too fast. ‘She’s a virgin…She’s a virgin…Careful…Easy does it…’ He chanted silently.
He rubbed her clit frantically with his thumb and lowered his head to take her nipple into his mouth as he slowly pushed himself inside. When he’d finally fit himself all the way inside, he gave a relieved sigh and kissed her, his hands pinching her nipples and rubbing her clit.
“Natsu…” She squirmed against him, stretched unbelievably far. It was slightly painful, the fit so tight she could feel him throbbing inside of her. His arms were locked tightly, muscles tense as he held himself back. ‘He’s so hard…’ She could tell it was difficult for him to give her time to adjust.
‘Oh Gods…she’s so tight. I didn’t realize it would be this hard to control myself. I had no idea she’d be so…perfect. I’m getting all fired up…’ He locked his muscles in place, forcing himself through sheer force of will to hold still. He needed to move, to fuck her hard… ‘I…won’t…hurt her.’ He focused his whole attention on her breasts, sucking them, licking them, circling her nipples with his tongue as he waited for her to find things pleasurable again. His hand wandered down to frantically rub her clit, knowing his control wouldn’t last indefinitely. He was determined to make it good for her. ‘I…won’t… hurt…Lucy…’
She gave a mewling cry, rocking her hips forward unconsciously as she neared another orgasm, still sensitive from her last. She couldn’t hold back the assortment of pleasured sounds escaping her throat. “N-Natsu! Oh Gods…yes!” She was vaguely aware of him beginning to thrust as she convulsed around him.
‘Oh Gods…she’s tightening up even more. I can feel her clenching around me…I can’t…I can’t resist this. I have to…move.’ He began to thrust against her, slowly at first, needing it like he needed to breathe. The desire was just that intense, it felt as urgent as a starving man’s need for food. As he felt her writhing in pleasure, his control snapped. Still rubbing her clit, he began to fuck her harder, burying his member deep with each thrust. He could feel himself hurtling towards orgasm even as he frantically pleasured her with his fingers. “Lucy…I can’t…I can’t hold on anymore…I’m sorry…”
He was barely even aware of the frantic rocking of her hips as his entire being focused on pounding into her slick heat. As his control snapped, he began to thrust as hard as he could, rubbing her clit frantically. He wanted to feel her clench around him again. He needed to hear the sexy little sounds she made. Primal urges took over and he bit her on the neck hard enough to bruise.
It was only when she began to cum around him again that he finally began to orgasm himself. A part of his mind urged him to pull out, a voice of reason warning him of the risk he took by staying inside of her, but his body refused to obey his command.
****
He came back to himself slowly, nuzzling her neck as he gave a contented sigh. When he regained his reason, he became aware of the bandits chanting. He jumped up, shielding the still dazed Lucy with his body.
Chimei smirked at him. "Excellent. That was quite the show." The chanting abruptly ended, and runes of light flew past him, affixing themselves to Lucy's stomach. Natsu's heart skipped a beat as he whipped around to check on her.
"What the fuck did you just do?!" He frantically checked her, even as her eyes opened and she sat up, blushing furiously and checking her clothes to make sure she was covered. Her hand went to the bite mark on her neck and she winced, sending a flash of guilt through Natsu.
"Nothing really. We just did a little fertility spell. Congrats! You're gonna be a daddy." Chimei laughed at the look of shock that filled their faces. "What? Didn’t you find it odd that your body refused to obey your commands? An incredibly strong spell was laid on the collar you wear, boy. Don't worry…your child will serve us well."
Natsu felt rage fill him, the hate overwhelming his already thin control. He'd never felt such anger, never hated anyone as much as he hated this man. He strode forward, stalking Chimei with deadly intent.
"You will NEVER touch my child!"
He punched Chimei in the face before the man could even ready a spell. Pouncing on him, he began to punch him mercilessly, his entire being focused on making the man pay. He was vaguely aware of the other bandits running his way, but his rage overwhelmed him. When Chimei was dead, pummeled to death, Natsu lifted his head. The bandits had surrounded him, and he gave a sadistic smile.
"You're all…going to die."
He ran forward and headbutted the first man in his path. His anger overwhelmed him and he lost himself in the fight. He ruthlessly cut through the bandits, his magic gone but his body deadly all on its own. His rage was so great that he was barely even aware of himself until he came to, covered in blood, after the fight was over. The bandits were all gone. Some were dead, some had fled, but none of them were a threat anymore.
He fell to his knees, an unimaginable throbbing pain coursing through him. He looked down and noticed for the first time a knife near his heart. He yanked it out, needing the pain to stop. The area went numb and he leaned forward onto his hand to support himself. Absentmindedly, he touched the stab wound in his chest with his free hand. It came away soaked in blood, and he felt himself growing very weak. "Lucy…I'm sorry." He collapsed forward.
"Natsuuuuuuuuu!" Her wail was the last thing he heard.
- 1
- 2
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Natsu's Choices